Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Controversial Gender Experiment

a. Did the Doctors take the right course of action after the accidental mutalation.?

b. What other methods or actinos could have been taken?

c. Who is to blame and how can this be avoided in the future.

d. Your overall thoughts and comments on this topic.

From the artcle "Man at centre of controversial gender experiment dies", A man in Winnipeg has died at the age of 38. His name is David Reimer. He chose to take his own life. The reason he chose to kill himself it's because he got a botched circumcision which mutilated him. The doctors who responsible to this castrated him and subjected him to years of female hormone treatments and psychological conditioning. They have hid the secret, not till he knew this at his teen age. He chose to be a men after he knows the fact, but depression and being outcast for so long. That's why he killed himself.

I feel the doctors should have possible repsond to this incident. Like tell him to accept the fact about his incident. Also a important things is, they shouldn't treat him as a experiment object. This is wrong for a human being. Therefore, they should be guilty for what they have done.

1 comments:

Tony Timbol said...

The majority of your response is a summary of the article... try expanding your answer...